Historic Fort Lauderdale Elks Lodge Engages in Legal Battle Over Property

A significant legal dispute has arisen concerning the ownership of the Pride of Fort Lauderdale Elks Lodge 652, a landmark deeply rooted in the city’s Black community. The trial, presided over by Judge Haines, pits the Grand Lodge of the Elks against Sader Investments, LLC, over the contested sale of the lodge’s property.

Historical Significance of the Elks Lodge

The Pride of Fort Lauderdale Elks Lodge 652 has long been a cornerstone for the local Black community, serving as a gathering place for politicians, business leaders, pastors, and activists. Its rich history underscores its importance as more than just a building; it symbolizes cultural heritage and community solidarity.

The Disputed Sale

Controversy erupted when Sader Investments claimed to have legally contracted with certain local lodge members to purchase the property. The company referenced records from Sunbiz.com, Florida’s official business entity index, to support their agreement with the lodge’s representatives.

However, the legitimacy of this transaction has been challenged. Leonard K. Polk, CEO of the International Grand Lodge of Elks, testified that the property ownership resides with the Grand Lodge, not the local members. This assertion undermines Sader Investments’ claim, suggesting that the local members may not have had the authority to sell the property.

Attempted Settlement and Trial Proceedings

Following the initial court session, an attempt was made to settle the dispute. The proposed agreement offered the Grand Lodge $2 million while granting Sader Investments ownership of the land. This settlement was deemed unacceptable, leading both parties to proceed to trial. Source:thewestsidegazette.com

The trial is expected to span ten days, with proceedings scheduled to conclude on March 14. The outcome could set a precedent for similar property disputes involving historic community institutions.

Implications for Historic Preservation

This case highlights the challenges faced by historic organizations in safeguarding their properties against external interests. The Broward Trust for Historic Preservation, a volunteer-driven non-profit organization, emphasizes the importance of preserving such historic structures for future generations.

The dispute underscores the need for clear property ownership records and the authority of local versus national organizational bodies in property transactions.